Run pre-upgrade tasks earlier and also run them for installation.

Review Request #12411 — Created June 24, 2022 and submitted

Information

Review Board
release-5.0.x

Reviewers

We had two major problems with our new pre-upgrade flows:

  1. We were running the pre-upgrade steps after the initial Evolver
    checks, which determine if an upgrade is required. This broke
    upgrades for oauth2_provider, since we couldn't reset the migration
    state early enough.

  2. We weren't running these steps on new installations when using
    manage.py createdb, so we never inserted the fake oauth2_provider
    migrations on any new development databases. This caused persisted
    system check failures on new installs. We did, however, run these on
    rb-site install.

This change addresses both issues. We now unconditionally run the
install steps in all cases, and we

At this point, these are no longer simply "upgrade" steps. They're
state setup/migration steps. So we may want to revisit some of the
naming and where this all lives. For now, though, this gets us through
the biggest of upgrade woes.

Successfully upgraded reviews.reviewboard.org with this change.

Tested creating new databases via manage.py createdb, and tested
upgrading.

New databases no longer had warnings about missing migrations.

Existing databases from pre-5.0 could be upgraded.

Existing databases from 5.0 correctly stated that an upgrade was
not required.

Summary ID
Run pre-upgrade tasks earlier and also run them for installation.
We had two major problems with our new pre-upgrade flows: 1. We were running the pre-upgrade steps after the initial `Evolver` checks, which determine if an upgrade is required. This broke upgrades for `oauth2_provider`, since we couldn't reset the migration state early enough. 2. We weren't running these steps on new installations when using `manage.py createdb`, so we never inserted the fake `oauth2_provider` migrations on any new development databases. This caused persisted system check failures on new installs. We did, however, run these on `rb-site install`. This change addresses both issues. We now unconditionally run the install steps in all cases, and we At this point, these are no longer simply "upgrade" steps. They're state setup/migration steps. So we may want to revisit some of the naming and where this all lives. For now, though, this gets us through the biggest of upgrade woes.
d26f5f1394d1e06e18f2b45a824c971b4b220de0
david
  1. Ship It!
  2. 
      
chipx86
Review request changed

Status: Closed (submitted)

Change Summary:

Pushed to release-5.0.x (66718d4)
Loading...